If you plan to replace your roof or build a new home, you’re probably considering two common choices: asphalt shingles vs metal roofing. Both are popular. Both protect your home. But they come with different price tags, lifespans, and maintenance needs.
So, how do you know which one is right for you?
If you’re like most homeowners we work with, you’re not just asking which one looks good, you want to know:
- Which one lasts longer?
- What costs more upfront, and what costs more over time?
- What works better for the weather we get in California?
- And ultimately, what’s going to give you peace of mind?
At Ground Up Construction, we’ve installed both asphalt and metal roofs throughout San Diego County, and we’ve seen the pros and cons of each up close.
This guide will walk you through the 7 key differences when comparing asphalt shingles vs metal roofing before making your decision.
Understanding the Basics: What Are Asphalt Shingles and Metal Roofing?
Asphalt Shingles
These are the most common type of residential roofing in the U.S. They come in flat, overlapping rectangles and are made from a fiberglass mat coated with asphalt and mineral granules. You’ve seen them everywhere.
Why people choose them: They’re affordable, easy to install, and come in lots of styles and colors.
Metal Roofing
Metal roofing comes in large panels or smaller shingle-like pieces and is made from steel, aluminum, or copper. The panels are either standing seam (vertical ridges) or stamped to look like shingles.
Why people choose it: It lasts a long time, is extremely durable, and reflects heat, making it energy-efficient in hot climates.
Key Difference #1: Cost Comparison – Upfront vs Long-Term
When comparing asphalt shingles vs metal roofing, cost is often the biggest factor homeowners consider.
Asphalt Shingles
- Material & installation cost: $4 to $7 per square foot
- Lifespan: 15–25 years
- Total lifetime cost (including replacement): Moderate
Metal Roofing
- Material & installation cost: $8 to $14 per square foot
- Lifespan: 40–70 years
- Total lifetime cost (including fewer replacements): Often lower in the long run
Verdict: Asphalt shingles are cheaper upfront, which makes them a better choice for tight budgets. But if you plan to stay in your home for 30+ years or more, a metal roof might save you money in the long term by avoiding a second roof replacement.
According to the National Roofing Contractors Association, homeowners should consider both initial costs and long-term value when making roofing decisions.
Key Difference #2: Durability and Weather Resistance
Understanding how asphalt shingles vs metal roofing perform in different weather conditions is crucial for California homeowners.
Asphalt Shingles
- Can blow off in high winds
- May crack under extreme heat
- Vulnerable to algae growth or curling in humid conditions
- Typically withstands wind up to 60–80 mph
Metal Roofing
- Stands up to winds over 120 mph
- Doesn’t crack, curl, or absorb water
- Resists fire and pests
- Can dent from large hail or falling branches
Verdict: Metal roofing wins on durability. It’s a better option for homes exposed to strong winds, wildfire risk, or intense sun, making it ideal for many areas in California. If you’re dealing with common roofing problems in San Diego homes, understanding durability differences is essential.
Key Difference #3: Style and Curb Appeal
The aesthetic comparison in asphalt shingles vs metal roofing often comes down to personal preference and neighborhood standards.
Asphalt Shingles
- Available in a wide range of colors and textures
- Fits well with traditional home designs
- Easier to match with neighboring homes or HOA requirements
Metal Roofing
- Sleek and modern look
- Also comes in styles that mimic shingles, tiles, or wood shakes
- Stands out more (may not blend in with certain neighborhoods)
Verdict: Style is subjective. If your home has a traditional design or you’re in a neighborhood with lots of shingle roofs, asphalt might be a better match. If you like a bold, clean look, or your home has a modern architectural style, metal roofing makes a statement.
For more inspiration, check out our guide on best roof designs for houses.
Key Difference #4: Energy Efficiency and Insulation
Energy performance is a major factor when weighing asphalt shingles vs metal roofing, especially in Southern California’s sunny climate.
Asphalt Shingles
- Absorbs heat, which can raise attic temperatures
- Newer shingles with reflective granules help reduce heat
- Still less efficient than metal
Metal Roofing
- Reflects solar heat, keeping attics cooler
- Can lower cooling costs by 10–25% in hot climates
- Often paired with radiant barriers or reflective coatings
Verdict: Metal roofs are more energy-efficient, especially in sunny places like Southern California. If lowering your energy bill is important, metal may be worth the extra investment.
The Department of Energy confirms that reflective roofing materials can significantly reduce cooling costs in warm climates.
Key Difference #5: Maintenance Needs
Maintenance requirements differ significantly when comparing asphalt shingles vs metal roofing.
Asphalt Shingles
- Needs regular inspection after storms
- Moss and algae can grow on shaded roofs
- Easy to patch if one shingle is damaged
Metal Roofing
- Little to no maintenance needed
- Occasional checks for loose fasteners or flashing
- Panels can last decades without fading or damage
Verdict: Asphalt needs more upkeep, especially as it ages. Metal roofing is more “set it and forget it.” Learn about roof maintenance challenges and how to overcome them to better understand ongoing care requirements.
Key Difference #6: Noise and Comfort
Sound transmission is another consideration in the asphalt shingles vs metal roofing debate.
Asphalt Shingles
- Naturally quiet
- Muffles sound from rain or hail well
Metal Roofing
- Can be louder during rain or hail without proper insulation
- Underlayment and attic insulation reduce noise
Verdict: With proper installation, metal roofing doesn’t have to be noisy, but shingles are quieter by default.
Key Difference #7: Environmental Impact
Sustainability concerns make environmental impact an important factor in asphalt shingles vs metal roofing decisions.
Asphalt Shingles
- Petroleum-based product
- Most end up in landfills after removal
- Not easily recyclable
Metal Roofing
- Often made from recycled materials
- Fully recyclable at the end of life
- Lasts longer, meaning fewer replacements
Verdict: Metal roofing is the greener choice. If sustainability matters to you, it’s a better long-term solution.
The Environmental Protection Agency recognizes metal roofing as an environmentally friendly building material due to its recyclability and energy efficiency.
Resale Value: How Each Option Affects Your Home’s Worth
A new roof always adds value, but which one adds more in the asphalt shingles vs metal roofing comparison?
Asphalt Shingles
- Standard upgrade in most markets
- Buyers may not be wowed, but it adds trust
Metal Roofing
- Seen as a high-end feature
- Attracts eco-conscious buyers
- Can boost home value more in modern or upscale neighborhoods
Verdict: If you’re flipping a home or plan to sell soon, asphalt may make sense. But if you’re upgrading your forever home or selling in a competitive market, metal can give you an edge.
So… Which Roofing Option Is Right for You?
Still not sure which to pick in the asphalt shingles vs metal roofing decision? Here’s a quick rundown based on your situation:
Choose Asphalt Shingles If:
- You’re working with a tight budget
- You only plan to stay in your home for a few more years
- You live in a neighborhood with traditional aesthetic or HOA restrictions
- You’re replacing your roof before selling your home
Choose Metal Roofing If:
- You’re planning to stay in your home for 20 years or more
- You want as little maintenance as possible
- Reducing your energy bills is a priority
- Your home has a modern or custom architectural style
Each roofing type has a place. It all comes down to what matters most to you. If you’re still unsure, read about how long roofs last to better understand lifecycle expectations.
Why Homeowners Trust Ground Up Construction for Roofing Advice
At Ground Up Construction, we’ve seen every kind of roof issue, from cracked shingles and rusted flashing to full roof rebuilds after fire or storm damage.
We’re not tied to one material. We install both asphalt and metal roofs depending on what’s best for you. Our roofing services help you compare options, see long-term cost impacts, and choose a roof that fits your home, your goals, and your budget.
We don’t guess. We don’t upsell. We give you honest, experienced advice, whether you’re replacing a few shingles or re-roofing the entire house.
Not Sure What to Pick? Let’s Walk Through It Together
Still deciding between asphalt shingles vs metal roofing? You don’t have to figure it all out on your own.
Schedule a no-pressure roofing consultation with Ground Up Construction today. We’ll:
- Inspect your current roof
- Review your goals and budget
- Show you side-by-side estimates
- Help you choose the best material for your home
Whether you need roof repair in San Diego or a complete replacement, we’re here to help. Your roof is one of your home’s biggest investments. Let’s get it done right, from the ground up.
If you’re experiencing issues right now, learn how to fix a leaky roof in 5 steps or contact us for immediate assistance.
